Read the 2 and 3-star reviews of the three biggest apps in your category, then search Reddit for "alternative to [app]" and "I wish there was an app". Collect about 100 complaints in users' own words, tag them with fixed themes, and count. The frequent, recent, painful theme is your opening.

This is for founders and indie makers looking for a problem worth solving, or checking whether theirs is real. The running example is a habit tracker for adults with ADHD, a category with many apps and many vocal users.

In short:

  • Middle reviews (2 and 3 stars) come from people who wanted the app to work.
  • Search operators like site:reddit.com find years of threads in minutes.
  • A fixed theme list makes AI tagging consistent and countable.
  • Copy quotes by hand or use official APIs. Don't scrape against the rules.

Middle reviews hold the useful complaints

One-star reviews are often about a bug or a billing fight. Five-star reviews say "love it". The 2 and 3-star reviews are where people explain what almost worked: "Great idea, but the streak resets if I miss one day and then I quit."

That sentence is a product requirement. It names the feature, the failure and the result.

Read reviews on the public store pages. Start with the most recent reviews, which matters because a complaint from 2021 may already be fixed. Apple explains how ratings and reviews work for developers. Google covers the same in Play Console's ratings and reviews help.

The official review APIs, such as the App Store Connect customer reviews API, only cover apps you own. For competitors, read the store pages, or use a review tool such as AppFollow, which collects public reviews across many apps. AppTweak offers similar data.

Reddit shows the workarounds people build

Reviews tell you what's wrong with existing apps. Forums tell you what people do instead. Workarounds are the strongest signal of a real problem: someone cared enough to build a spreadsheet, a sticky-note system or a five-alarm routine.

Google often finds old Reddit threads faster than Reddit's own search. Google documents the site: operator. Its help page lists other search refinements like quotes for exact phrases.

Queries that work for the habit tracker example:

site:reddit.com "habit tracker" ADHD
            site:reddit.com "alternative to" habit app
            site:reddit.com "I wish there was an app" routine
            site:reddit.com "gave up on" habit tracker
            

Add the current or last year to the query to see recent threads. For developer or startup tools, Hacker News search by Algolia does the same job for Hacker News comments.

To keep watching after the first pass, a free alert tool like F5Bot emails you when a keyword appears on Reddit or Hacker News.

Collect 100 quotes in five steps

A fixed amount keeps this from turning into endless scrolling. One evening is enough.

  1. Pick the three apps with the most reviews in your category.
  2. Copy 20 recent 2 and 3-star reviews from each, on both stores if possible.
  3. Search Reddit with the queries above and copy 40 relevant comments.
  4. Paste everything into one sheet: quote, source, date, star rating if any.
  5. Remove usernames. You need the words, not the person.

Follow each site's rules while you do this. Reddit's Data API terms set the conditions for automated access. Reddit's rules cover behaviour on the site. Reading and copying a hundred quotes by hand is fine. Running a scraper is a different question.

Tag quotes with a fixed theme list

AI assistants are good at tagging, but only if you give them the categories. Ask them to invent themes and you get a new set every time, which you can't count.

Write five to eight themes after reading the first 20 quotes yourself. For the habit tracker, they might be: streak anxiety, too many reminders, setup takes too long, no flexibility for bad days, subscription price, sync bugs, and other.

Then paste the sheet into an assistant with a prompt like this:

Tag each quote with ONE theme from this list:
            streak anxiety, too many reminders, setup too long,
            no flexibility for bad days, price, sync bugs, other.
            Return a table: quote number, theme, pain (1 to 3).
            Pain 3 means the person quit or switched.
            Do not change the quotes. Do not add themes.
            

Spot-check ten tags yourself. If more than two are wrong, sharpen the theme names and run it again.

Score themes by frequency, pain and recency

Counting alone misleads, because one angry thread can produce twenty quotes. Score each theme on three things: mentions, quits and recency.

In the habit tracker example, the scoring points away from the most common complaint:

Theme Mentions Quit or switched Recent (12 months)
Streak anxiety 24 11 17
Too many reminders 18 3 9
No flexibility for bad days 15 9 13
Price 21 2 20

These numbers are illustrative, not from a real dataset. Price gets many mentions but few people quit over it. Streak anxiety and rigid schedules make people leave, which is a design problem a new app can fix. For more on streak design, see how streaks work as rewards.

Turn the top theme into a testable promise

The winning theme becomes a headline you can test. "A habit tracker that doesn't punish bad days" comes straight from the quotes. Use the users' own phrases on the page, because those are the words the next person will recognise.

Then test it with real people before you build. A landing page smoke test tells you whether the promise gets sign-ups.

Where GrowApps fits after the mining

When you start a new app in GrowApps, it runs its own short research rounds on apps like yours and shows the findings on a research board with links to the pages it read (how GrowApps works).

Paste your top themes and a few quotes into that first message. The research and the screen designs then start from the problems you found, not from a generic habit tracker.

Read twenty reviews tonight

Open the store page of the biggest app in your category. Sort by most recent, filter to 2 and 3 stars if the store allows it, and copy twenty reviews into a sheet. Underline every workaround and every "I quit because". Then read the full market research workflow with AI agents for the next step.

Frequently asked questions

Reading public reviews and quoting short excerpts for your own research is common practice. Automated collection is governed by each site's terms, so read them first. Don't publish personal details, and don't reuse long passages in marketing without permission.

How many reviews are enough?

About 100 quotes across three apps and a few threads usually shows the main themes. If new quotes keep adding new themes after 100, your category may be too broad.

Sources and further reading